After reading all four books this semester, I found
Christian Parenti’s Tropic of Chaos
the most interesting. While I believe Kristof and WuDunn’s book Half the Sky is more culturally relevant
given society’s plight of women, I enjoyed Tropic
of Chaos and believed it to be historically relevant. Before I declared a sociology
minor, I was briefly a history minor. I have always been a student of history,
and I thoroughly enjoyed Parenti’s in-depth history of these third-world Asian
and African countries. Their histories seem to have been glossed over and
forgotten by nearly everyone. Thus, I found Tropic
of Chaos refreshing, as it was not American (my favorite subject), British,
nor Roman history. It was not the same rigmarole that is taught to primary and
secondary students: It was detailed, extravagant, and new; I had never learned
this before. Thus, I believe that this “new” history should be instructed to
explain the plight of dozens of countries worldwide.
Parenti starts his geography of violence by asking a
simple question: Who killed Ekaru Loruman? Loruman was a Kenyan farmer who was
killed by a rival tribe, the Pokot. One would think that statement would answer
Parenti’s question; however, Parenti wanted to go deeper. Saying Loruman was
killed by a rival tribe is simple, but was there an additional or external
factor that influenced his death? According to Parenti’s research, there was
someone else responsible: Everyone else. Parenti claims that rising global
temperatures indirectly led to Loruman’s death. Simply, global warming
instigates violence in countries devoid of resources. I was not a big fan of
Parenti’s agenda, as he continuously implied that global warming is the reason
for the problems in our world. Despite his underlying message, Parenti does a
magnificent job in the ensuing chapters of explaining the destructive histories
of nations like Uganda, Kenya, and Kyrgyzstan. His explanation of these
histories overcomes his shortcomings as a messenger. Parenti is a historian, and
he should avoid becoming political. His masterful historical storytelling
should be commended, while his political agenda denounced.
The most fascinating histories detailed include those of
Uganda and Somalia. Uganda is a failed state brought about by British imperialism.
Ruled by Great Britain, Uganda earned its independence in the early 1960s. Formerly
known as Buganda, the country soon delved into a military dictatorship under
Idi Amin Dada. Amin seized ivory and gold from covert raids in the Congo in the
1960s, adding to his infamy. After seizing power in Uganda in 1971, Amin
threatened Tanzania with force and turned Uganda into a “kleptocracy” founded
on stealing goods from neighboring countries. Amin built Uganda’s military
strength with Soviet aid. Weapons flowed into Uganda, and its economy became dilapidated.
The U.S. placed a trade embargo on Uganda in 1978. In October 1978, Amin went
to war in Tanzania, and he watched his military fall apart around him. Uganda
has since failed to develop any form of stable government and weapons trafficking
has remained a significant problem. Parenti does a fantastic job of explaining the
history of Uganda. I knew Uganda was once a British colony, but the history of Amin
and his military rule was new to me. I credit Parenti for explaining the
shadows of African history.
Somalia
was also a European colony. Italy controlled the south, while the British ruled
in the north. Somalia gained independence in 1960 and endured nine years of
experimental democracy. However, in 1969, Mohammed Siad Barre led a military
coup and seized power. At the peak of the Cold War, the Soviet Union sought the
alliance with four socialist states, one of them being Somalia. The Soviets
hoped an alliance with Somalia would lead to control over the shipping lanes feeding
to the Middle East and the Mediterranean (through the Red Sea and the Suez
Canal). In 1977, Somalia went to war with Ethiopia to reclaim the Ogaden, an
Ethiopian territory inhabited by Somalis. However, the Soviets fed supplies to
Ethiopia, while the Cubans sent infantry and pilots. The war in ended in 1978,
and Somalia never recovered from its defeat in the Ogaden War. The cost of the
war crippled Somalia’s economy, as the national debt approached $300 million by
1979; the debt reached $1.9 billion by 1990. Siad Barre lost control of
Mogadishu in early 1991, and the country remains without a functioning
government. Somalia continues to be affected by weapons trafficking, and it
remains a dangerous and hostile country. Again, I only knew the initial background
of Somalia, such as its colonization until the 1960s and its economic failures
of the 1990s and 2000s. Parenti dedicated an entire chapter to Somalia, and the
recent history of the country (1960-present) is extremely fascinating. I
believe everyone should know this extensive history, and I am glad to have read
Parenti’s book, as it has given me insight about the histories of third-world
nations.
Since
I was little, I have always enjoyed learning history. American history has
always been my favorite subject, as I love to learn about the Revolutionary War,
the Civil War, and World War II. However, I did not garner much education about
the histories of other nations. Granted, I did learn about the history of
nations like Mexico, Spain, Great Britain, France, and Italy. Students in our
generation do not get the chance to learn about third-world countries. They may
not want to learn it, for they believe that it will not benefit them in the
future, and perhaps they are right. How often does one need to know the history
of Uganda at a moment’s notice? It might not be necessary, but it is always
good to look at the past. Looking into the past can always provide an explanation
for the troubles of our world. History is bound to repeat itself, and I would
rather know that history and prevent those mistakes from reoccurring than be
devoid of that knowledge and face a scenario unprepared. Parenti’s historical
analysis made this book easy to read and enjoy, in my opinion. While I did not
like his message in Tropic of Chaos,
his storytelling was fascinating. History will always be relevant, and I
believe Parenti was masterful in writing Tropic
of Chaos.
No comments:
Post a Comment