Sunday, April 8, 2012
Sunday, April 1, 2012
Goldstein Ch. 9-12
Goldstein
continues his pro-UN rant in the final chapters of his book Winning the War on War. He begins the
last section with a chapter regarding a potential peace increase since the end
of World War II. This chapter seeks to determine whether the United Nations has
been successful in keeping peace around the world. There is no total number of
wars since 1945, for there is too much squabble over the definition of war. Goldstein
does, however, indicate that battle-related deaths have declined significantly
over the past 70 years. Believe it or not, UN peacekeeping has had an effect.
Public perception of war does not
support that statistic, for they claim that civilians are the overwhelming
majority of casualties. This is a myth, and the most significant of the three
laid out in Chapter 10. He ends the book with a call to action. He tries to lay
out some ideals with which Americans can use to support the UN. He distinctly points
out that the UN is a collection of nations, not people. We are brothers and
sisters in God’s eyes, and we must unite to keep order around the globe.
I
believe Goldstein used this book as personal propaganda. Perhaps this is my
biased view of the UN coming into the picture, but I believe Goldstein is too
UN-heavy. This book did have some interesting statistics and provided me with a
history of the UN of which I was not aware. Goldstein should write history books.
Quiz Question: Why can there not be a total number of wars
since 1945?
Research Question: How and why did the number of
battle-related deaths decline since the end of World War II?
Sunday, March 18, 2012
Goldstein Ch. 5-8
Peace is in everyone’s best
interest. However, some squabble over the procurement of said peace. Goldstein,
over the course of chapters five through eight, discusses the widespread
reaches of UN peacekeeping. The United Nations seeks to maintain and keep peace
around the globe through a multinational coalition and an extravagant form of
diplomacy. However, the UN is not as ineffective as it appears. He details the
recent history of UN Secretary General Kofi Annan, his rise to power, and his
fall from grace in the mid-2000s. He goes on to discuss the UN peace operation in
Sierra Leone, among other nations, as they fought a vicious civil war. The
amount of history and detail included in each chapter is staggering; it is very
similar to a political history book. Filled with demographics and statistics,
these chapters certainly detail and explain the operation of the United
Nations.
The United States has a very narrow
opinion of the United Nations. Americans view the UN as “soft,” a collection of
nations afraid to step up to the plate and take on conflicts with a full head
of steam. However, this is just a biased opinion, as the US views the UN’s “diplomacy”
as “fear of reality.” Honestly, I have succumbed to those beliefs about the
United Nations, mainly from their portrayal in films and in the news media.
These depictions are unfair, as they do not give credence to the amount of
peacekeeping the UN conducts around the world. These chapters provided an
elongated timeline for each peacekeeping operation, and I found that extremely interesting.
Quiz Question: What was the Abidjan Accord?
Research Question: How effective is the UN at peacekeeping?
Triangulate the Truth: Iran's Nuclear Program
Iran has been constructing a nuclear program for the past few
years. Iran claims that the program is for civilian purposes, while the United
States, Israel, and the West believe Iran is seeking the development of nuclear
weapons. A nuclear weapon program in Iran would only destabilize the region
even more and could potentially lead to World War III. However, this topic has
garnered much media attention in recent weeks. Israel and the United States have
stood firm against Iran, but Iranian media paints an entirely different
picture.
In a recent
article from The New York Times, the
United States is portrayed as the diplomatic party in the negotiations. Israel,
a major contributor in the talks, has considered military action against Iran.
According to the Times, Israel
appears eager to strike Iran. The United States, however, appears patient and
diplomatic in its search for peace. The article even drives a wedge through
bipartisanship; President Obama and his liberal cohorts want negotiation, while
Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell and the Republicans want a pre-emptive military
strike on Iran’s nuclear facilities. The Times
article indicates bias in favor of the United States and successfully paints
the Iranian government as hostile and unbalanced.
Iranian
newspapers, however, portray a different story. The Tehran Times, a large newspaper for the capital of Iran, explains
the opposite of The New York Times
article. In Iran, the West appears weak and pressured. The article claims the
West, under the supervision of the United States and Israel, wants to divide
the Iranian government and its people. The article explains, however, that the
Iranians support their government and will not overthrow it simply because of
the pressures of the West. The Tehran
Times believes that President Obama’s threat of military action is a bluff
in an attempt for the United States to gain the upper hand in negotiations. The
article ends with a simple saying: the West is afraid of Iran’s capabilities.
The Tehran Times is obviously biased
in favor of Iran.
BBC News offered the most unbiased view
of the situation. The article does not choose one side; according to the BBC article, there is not good and evil,
black and white. Israel, the article claims, is at the center of a possible
military strike, while also claims that diplomacy is still the best option. In contrast
to the other two articles, the one from BBC
News provides context for Iran’s nuclear programs. It explains that the
economic sanctions imposed on Iran are drastically affecting the Iranian
economy, and it clearly states that Iran has agreed to return to the negotiations.
BBC also provides risks for a
potential military strike, which neither The
New York Times nor the Tehran Times
article included. Overall, the BBC News
article offered a more realistic and unbiased view of the squabble over Iran’s
nuclear program.
Wednesday, March 14, 2012
Amandla! Power to the People!
South
African apartheid oppressed millions and supported white supremacy. However,
the oppressed Africans turned to music to fuel their revolution. The film began
with the exhumation of Vuyisile Mini, a deceased anti-apartheid activist. Mini
was a leader for the blacks in their conquest for equality and justice in South
Africa. However, he was executed by the apartheid government in 1964. Told through
the stories and perspectives of several activists and musicians, the
documentary Amandla! focuses on the
role of music in the revolution for basic human rights.
In
South Africa, individuals came together to sing and chant. Music was their
resistance to the oppression, and the citizens of South Africa sought equality.
It was not just the singing: it was how they sang. The tone of their chants
played a factor in their resistance. One of the greatest leaders against
apartheid, Nelson Mandela fought against the oppressive government until he
found himself in prison. The indigenous people sang for years, hoping to see
the day Mandela would be set free. He was finally released in February 1990
after the fall of apartheid. He eventually would become President of South
Africa.
I found
this documentary interesting. I vaguely remember learning about South African
apartheid in prior courses, but I do recall some mention of it. It was
interesting to see the effects of music on a social revolution, as literally
millions of people came together to fight oppression. They did not fight with
bullets or guns. Their weapons were simple: their voices.
Saturday, March 10, 2012
Invisible Children/Kony 2012: Bring Him Down
Make him famous. Stop Joseph Kony. These are the primary
objectives of the films Invisible
Children and Kony 2012. Over
30,000 children have been kidnapped by the monster Joseph Kony and forced to
serve in his army. The Lord’s Resistance Army, or LRA, of Uganda, under the
supervision of Kony, has been conducting this “business” for over 20 years. If
this crime was not bad enough, it has gone relatively unnoticed over that time
frame. Thanks to these two films, the disturbing and tragic story has been
portrayed to the world and has been made available to millions. Now, with the
recent publication of Kony 2012, the
world has been called together to support the arrest of Joseph Kony and the
release of his child soldiers. The slogan is unique and calls for action: make
Kony famous to advocate his capture.
Kony
not only captures and kidnaps these children, he threatens them. The boys are
forced into his army and trained to kill. The girls become sex slaves and are
often subjected to cruel behavior. All this occurs at the whim of a madman. Children
cannot escape from these internment camps, for Kony and the LRA will execute
anyone who tries. Jacob, one of the Ugandan boys in Invisible Children, describes the night that his brother was
murdered by the LRA for attempting to escape. He is just one of many children
affected by Kony and his despicable cohorts.
I find
it extremely discouraging to learn that these crimes have occurred for over two
decades without international intervention. Uganda possesses no major natural
resources, such as oil, and poses no threat to American sovereignty. However,
that does not mitigate these crimes. Human rights extend beyond that of national
interests, and this criminal should be apprehended, tried, and convicted by the
International Criminal Court. I was influenced by these films heavily, for I
believe it is an injustice to let Joseph Kony continue to kidnap innocent
children and coerce them into an army. He has evaded capture, but now that will
change. Joseph Kony must pay for his crimes. We will make him famous, and we
will bring him to justice.
Monday, March 5, 2012
Parenti: Final Thoughts
Throughout Parenti’s book Tropic of Chaos, he routinely discusses the impact of climate change on violence. While it is certainly a topic that is rarely discussed in the grand scheme of violence, it is not one that we can overlook. This is an aspect of our everyday lives. We know the climate is heating up and the ozone is shrinking, but most do not know that these rising temperatures instigate violence half way around the world. That is one thing I have learned from Parenti and his book. I was unaware of the impact climate change has on violence until reading his book. Granted, these were just some depictions and stories of what is likely a long list of victimized nations. He did a great job explaining the historical aspect of each nation, but he could have been broader and covered more ground.
Parenti, however, failed to examine certain countries. He focused on Somalia, Kenya, Uganda, Afghanistan, and Kyrgyzstan among others, but he failed to mention or describe the scenarios of Eastern European or Southwest Asian nations. This might have helped prove his point that climate change is having a global effect on violence. The sample of 19 or 20 countries do not explain the effects of the entire world.
However, Parenti was able to prove his point: climate change does instigate violence, and as temperatures increase, violence increases. His book is certainly intriguing and fascinating, but more information on different countries could have strengthened his argument that violence is caused by rapid global climate shifts. As Americans and human beings, we must band together to fight this problem that we have brought upon ourselves.
Quiz Question: What does NAFTA stand for? List the countries involved in NAFTA.
Research Question: Does NAFTA have regulations on North American carbon emissions?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)